FoodPlacee Passport United States · South Dakota · 55147
Verified Godfather's Pizza Express
New Underwood, South Dakota, USA
Rating★ 4.4 / 5
Price$1–10
CategoryPizza Restaurant
Today 09:30 AM - 08:00 PM
Food Place Passport
Godfather's Pizza Express in South Dakota
Discover a relaxed atmosphere and affordable pizza options at Godfather's Pizza Express, located on Hwy 1416 in New Underwood.
16098 Hwy 1416, New Underwood, SD 57761, United States
Overview
About This Food Place
Gallery
Photos from Godfather's Pizza Express
Real shots of the food, atmosphere, and signature dishes at this location.
Guest sentiment
What People Feel
A snapshot of what local diners frequently mention about this location.
SR
Shane Rucker 2 month ago
"Ordered some pizza and it was nice and filling. Their guy back there knows what he's doing and needs a raise! Couldn't have asked for a better pizza."
AH
Andrew Hentz 2 month ago
"Great Bicycle Shop. Knowledgable, skilled and pleasent mechanical and sales staff. Jesse and the crew offer clients good technical and sales advice on modern bicycles, tools and equipment. It's a fun place to just look around or make purchases. The shop is well layed out and interesting. The oroducts offered are generally high grade in quality and are priced accordingly. It's not often that you hear from them they can order what you need because generally it's stocked which is a welcome reprise in the bike shop world."
M
MaryK 3 month ago
"Stopped in for a Godfather’s Pizza fix and we left FAT & HAPPY!!! We had stopped into the one off of Blackhawk Road but were disappointed that they are closed until further notice so we hightailed it up I-90 east to New Underwood because WE WERE NOT going to settle for anything less than some great Godfather’s Pizza!!! Kudos to the seemingly “one man show”!!! Great pies!"
L
Loxnezz 3 month ago
"For a pizza place in a gas station the food was great. And it came out fast evan tho there was only one guy there. And a large 8 slice is only 12 bucks. This is a must have"
BK
brad krapff 4 month ago
"As always this is what a pizza should taste like. When you drive 40 miles round trip for the Best Pizza in all the West River of South Dakota Well, that says it all. The one man show of Tyler has been put to the test in the variety of menu options. Not once ever disappointing us. Personel favorite Cheeseburger pizza hold the pickles. But even a basic pepperoni scores big points!"
AM
Azele Marquise 4 month ago
"Best pizza i ever had. Sauce was light but you could taste the tomato and herbs. The cheese was melted over the toppings which kept the toppings from falling off. All in all it was an amazing middle of nowhere diamond in the rough. A true hidden gem"
LW
Lori Wendland 5 month ago
"Very quiet, kinda Creepy Quiet... But AWESOME STAFF & PIZZA"
WC
Winston Clapper 5 month ago
"Very good pizza! There isn’t much else for miles, but this really exceeded all of my expectations! Wish there was one near me"
Visit info
When to Visit
Weekly hours below — always confirm with the business before holidays or special events.
Today Closed
| Monday | 09:30 AM - 08:00 PM |
| Tuesday | 09:30 AM - 08:00 PM |
| Wednesday | 09:30 AM - 08:00 PM |
| Thursday | 09:30 AM - 08:00 PM |
| Friday | 09:30 AM - 08:00 PM |
| Saturday | 09:30 AM - 08:00 PM |
| Sunday | 09:30 AM - 08:00 PM |
Hours may change. Please confirm with the business before visiting.
On the map
Where This Food Place Lives
Find your way to Godfather's Pizza Express in South Dakota .
Address 16098 Hwy 1416, New Underwood, SD 57761, United States
Phone +1 605-754-6778
Area South Dakota
Call Address copied ✓
Questions answered
Food Place Questions
Find answers to common questions about Godfather's Pizza Express in New Underwood, including menu options, services, and accessibility.
Open daily from 9:30 AM to 8:00 PM, Godfather's Pizza Express serves customers throughout the week. Hours and availability may vary, so checking ahead is recommended.
Yes, delivery, takeaway, dine-in, and on-site services are available, providing flexible dining options to suit different preferences.
Yes, the location features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, parking, and restroom facilities to accommodate guests with mobility needs.
Specializing in thick-crust pizzas, the menu includes specialty pies, create-your-own pizzas, sides like breadsticks and cheesesticks, desserts, and beverages. Menu options may change.
Reservations are accepted, making it easier for groups and families to plan their visits in advance, especially during peak times.
The restaurant offers a casual atmosphere and is good for kids, welcoming families and tourists alike for lunch or dinner.
Payments can be made using credit cards and debit cards, ensuring convenient and secure transactions.
Nearby brands
Related food places near Godfather's Pizza Express
Other casual restaurants and brands diners often visit in South Dakota.
For owners
Own or manage this food place?
Update this page with accurate hours, menu details, photos, and business notes — and reach food lovers searching for places like yours on FoodPlacee.
Menus, prices, hours, services, and availability may change. Please contact the food place directly before visiting or ordering.